Mason v Laing

The Portal rules are strict; if in a soft tissue injury claim the first report is not disclosed before subsequent ones, a Claimant cannot rely on the subsequent reports.

Greyson v Fuller

A claimant failed to disclose a first report before a subsequent report, so were held to be in breach of para 7.8A of the RTA Protocol.  However, the judge allowed the claimant Relief from Sanction.  

Please note this has been appealed to the High Court as of 19th April 20201, and judgment is awaited.

Moesaid v Calder

Where a subsequent report took the claim out of the definition of soft tissue injury claim, it did not matter when the reports were disclosed, the special rules on soft tissue injuries did not apply.

Go Back to Index 

Click on the button below to go back to the case law index